You linked 3 shields, all of them are lacking either healing, int or mp5. You cant combine them and get each of all the stats, right?
.
Yeah, so what? You yourself recommended him that
you should try to just get items with +healing, int and mp5.
The point here is, next post, you tell a new player that "there is no good shield", which is not true.
Ofc there is good shields you get from raids but we were talking about shields pre-raid? Best shield drops from Kel'thusad and next best is an offhand from Sapphiron, thats just how it goes. There will be offhands that are better than shields, and shields thats better than offhands.
Now you said yourself that there are good shields, then I don't get why would you tell a player this:
unfortunately there just isnt any shields with the right stats.
:blink:
Theres a lot of bosses where theres simply no way you will get aggro/take physical damage, so having that extra armor just becomes useless.
Panthers, Backstab and possibly even Whirlwind on High Priest Arlokk?
Charge from Mandokir, Mar'li, Jeklik, Thekal?
Mindcontrolled raid member at Lucifron or Hakkar?
Unbanished minion of Garr?
Skeleton Drakonids on Nefarian?
There are so many ways to take physical damage I can't even remember them all.
in raids where you going for progression
Especially in raids where you are going to progress, the kill won't be flawless, there will be mistakes, and the chance something smashes your face is that much higher than on a farm raid.