I can sum up this thread and the one in general discussion so we can just close this topic once and for all:
I've been playing here for almost a year now, Alliance has won roughly 70% of all the AV's I've played during my time. I guess thats fairly similar to vanilla because as Lharts and others posted before the map IS favored for alliance. Yes horde standing on the ledges is an advantage/exploit/clever usage of game mechanics, but considering the druids and everything else I would say that horde is still at a disadvantage.
Now there is basically 2 types of alliance in AV: the PvE carebears and the PvP oriented people who actually know how to play. The alliance team is usually a mix of these player types. On horde the division is nowhere near this significant, as most are fairly pvp oriented with varying skill levels.
What happened in the last month: Most of War Sole skipped AV weekend which lead to alliance having worse teams than usual. Losing made the PVE carebears furious: "but we are gud players we must be losing cos stupid horde exploit, kk time is make forum post!"
I didnt play this weekend but it seems like things returned to pretty normal or maybe the gap was even wider this week dunno but to sum it all up:
-AV map is favored for Alliance
-Alliance sucks but is carried by War Sole
-GMs are Illuminati and against horde always (druids hello!!? after 1 year still not fixed)
kkthxbye