They will never catch up to a guild that has 205 warlocks capable of summoning 5 geared alts per person across the globe.
They will never catch up to a guild that had 6 extra months of AQ and 6 more of BWL/MC with multiple equally geared alts they leveled with an exp event.
Perhaps this is true for Vanguard, but certainly not for us.
Our guild has 3 lvl 45 warlocks right now, logged in to check.
We also have two AQ-geared alts (one is never at world bosses), not more. Some BWL from the Risen PuG, but most of us have not been playing here for a year, so we don't have these old BWL chars either.
But that is also why we get a few, and not all of them, and it's totally fine
Others put more effort into it.
Let me just summarize some of the stuff here.
The main issue Pip is trying to "fix" here in his own words is that we have little open world pvp here. That was always so fun in old memories from 12 years ago, because you spent a few evenings mindlessly zerging in Tarren's Mill, at least for him and few others. Seems though that not that many 60's that are kinda geared enjoy this, otherwise this would happen more often organicly, or on set dates on forums. Does not happen too much. So, what you should conclude from that is, that it is just not that much fun for most, so don't force your wishes on everyone trying to get your own personal fix. If you really "only" started for worldpvp, you chose the wrong game, i am sorry, but open world pvp sucks anyways. Wait for Arena, play a different pvp-game, with better balance hopefully, play some Go if you think you are that smart, or perhaps try real fighting sports in rl to push you.
But okay, let's say your intent is to bolster world pvp, and really push the alliance on it to create unknown and unwanted fun for most players, then i don't get this situation. You have roughly 35-45 hordes at Lethon, you have complete control of the most prized dragon, in your words. There is a few alliance spies, but nothing major, since they went to other dragons first. What is the logical choice to do? Kill him as fast as possible?
Surely not. IF your goals would be the ones stated by you, you would never attack Lethon, guard him, clear the trash to have more open room, and wait for us to come to him. Alliance would take some time to kill the others, and then converge onto your spot, bringing you exactly what you want, and you even have the high ground to bolster the advantage for some neat pvp. But wait, this didn't happen. You just killed him fast and were glad no one showed up to interrupt you. Way to go and prove that you are all about the loot after all?
If i remember right, the timers on Emerald Dragons were done so more people could gather up since the NR loot is important for AQ40. Never really agreed but okay. Most everyone trying for this does not need the NR gear, it's nice small upgrades but not needed, on both sides i am sure. So, just remove all timers from all bosses, not add timers to the others. I am totally aware that we probably will loose more bosses this way, because we also lack infrastructure, but it does reward the ones who put in the most work. Having a timer on these bosses will become old shortly. Taggingbattles are just the worsed, i think everyone can agree. Having hours of worldpvp in addition to taggingwars will only lead to one thing, very little people showing up to them anymore, since after your own admission, the loot is not that great. So, again, no awesome worldbosspvp that you are missing from 12y ago, but no one else who really did it back then, misses.